Andrew McDonald denies claims Australia has underachieved during Pat Cummins' captaincy as winning away tours continues to provide the greatest challenge
'Incredibly frustrated': McDonald rues a lead squandered
Head coach Andrew McDonald believes broader context must be placed around Australia's performances after they left South Africa with just a second series defeat out of 16 played in the Pat Cummins era.
In their first Test in Cape Town since the 2018 sandpaper scandal, the Australians were humbled on the final day of the series decider; bowled out for 111 after falling to 7-60 in the morning session amid their pursuit of 288.
It was their second batting debacle in as many matches, after they were skittled for 99 in the first innings of the second Test in Gqeberha.
The response in the Australian media and public has been severe, with questions asked over selection and strategy ahead of big Test series against New Zealand, India and England across the next 12 months.
And while McDonald acknowledged the series outcome had been disappointing, he was also framing it in the lens of a successful period in which Australia have won 11 Test series and drawn three – losing only to the Proteas and India (2023) away since Cummins' appointment as skipper in December 2021.
"We've underachieved here (in South Africa)," he said. "I think people put a lot of premium on the key series, and that's ultimately where you are judged. We understand that.
"I wouldn't say that we've underachieved … if you actually put a bit of context around (that record).
"I also don't want to judge on previous generations. The world game, I think, has far more depth at the moment … and that's not to dismiss the previous generation. I don't want to get into this generational war; we have the utmost respect for what they did.
"But it feels as though it's hard to win on the road, and that's the greatest challenge, and that's where we will be critiqued."
Australia's Test results on the road in the Cummins era have been mixed, with series wins in Pakistan, New Zealand, Sri Lanka and West Indies, as well as their World Test Championship Final triumph over India at The Oval in 2023.
Together with defeats in India and South Africa however, they have also squandered series leads in England (two-nil to two-all) and Sri Lanka (one-nil to one-all) away from home.
Surrendering a one-nil lead to the Proteas was the aspect of the series defeat McDonald said he was "incredibly frustrated" by, and with good reason; not since India's famous mid-series turnaround in Kolkata 2001 has Australia lost a three-match Test series after leading one-nil.
Meanwhile, three defeats in Australia's past five Test matches leaves Cummins with a remarkably similar captaincy record to his contemporary, Steve Smith. Both skippers have won 26 and lost 11 matches in charge, with Smith having drawn seven to Cummins' six.
Cummins' win percentage of 60.46 places him third among Australia captains (min 25 Tests), with only Steve Waugh (71.92) and Ricky Ponting (62.33) ahead of him.
The current skipper has been in the job a month short of five years – a longer stretch than Waugh, Mark Taylor and Michael Clarke – while the tenure of his leadership partner McDonald will be reviewed at the end of his current contract, which ends after next year's ODI World Cup in South Africa.
"There has been some discussion, so I won't hide away from that," he said of his contract. "But my firm focus is we've got 10 Test matches in the next three months, so I'm looking at that.
"We're always continuing to discuss what everything looks like with every staff member, the workloads that are attached to that … But as it sits at the moment, my focus is this next period of time up to the 150th (anniversary Test against England next March).
"Then we'll get April-May to sit back and look at it and plan for an Ashes, and ahead of that hopefully a World Test Championship (Final), albeit we're a little bit up against it (to make that) now."
Australia v New Zealand Tests 2026
First Test: December 9-13, Perth Stadium, 1:20pm AEDT
Second Test: December 17-21, Adelaide Oval, 11:30am AEDT
Third Test: December 26-30, MCG, Melbourne, 10:30am AEDT
Fourth Test: January 4-8, SCG, Sydney, 10:30am AEDT